• Categories
    • Climate Change
    • Fresh Water
    • Marine and Coastal
    • Native Wildlife
      • Bird of the Year
    • Native Plants & Forests
    • Threats & Impacts
  • Support Us
  • Join Us
Forest & Bird Forest & Bird Forest & Bird Forest & Bird
  • Categories
    • Climate Change
    • Fresh Water
    • Marine and Coastal
    • Native Wildlife
      • Bird of the Year
    • Native Plants & Forests
    • Threats & Impacts
  • Support Us
  • Join Us

Mining Schedule 4 bad economics

May 31, 2010 | Posted by Quentin Duthie |

Blogger: Forest & Bird conservation advocate Quentin Duthie

There’s an old saying that a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush.

It’s sort of true with mining in Schedule 4 lands too.

To stretch the metaphor to the case of Schedule 4 mining, getting the ‘bird’ buried under the bush will mean we lose the bird in hand and the two in the bush.

We’ll also badly damage the bush itself, and potentially scare off quite a few of the 1.6 million birds* that fly in to enjoy the bush every year.

This is pretty much the overall conclusion of three economics reports that Forest & Bird commissioned and appended to its submission on Schedule 4 mining.

They’re well worth a read, along with our submission.

Update: Celebrated physicist Professor Sir Paul Callaghan concurs. He said last week that the Government’s plans to mine on conservation land are “stupid economics”.

* 1.6 million international tourists participate in nature-based activities in New Zealand each year

stockton

Share

About Quentin Duthie

This author hasn't written their bio yet.
Quentin Duthie has contributed 4 entries to our website, so far. View entries by Quentin Duthie.

You also might be interested in

Hidden Wealth

Apr 13, 2012

Spotlighting the lives of the ‘small and insignificant’ has been[...]

Doing things the old way gets the West Coast nowhere

Doing things the old way gets the West Coast nowhere

Jul 14, 2017

Thursday was a big day. A massive iceberg 10 times the[...]

Micro-world

Mar 8, 2013

Recently, I got the chance to head down to the[...]

Subscribe

Recent Posts

  • Marine protection misses Catlins coast
  • Above the treeline: sorting tahr fact from fiction
  • By failing to protect our water we have failed everything New Zealanders value
  • Forest & Bird Youth calls for investment in nature
  • Policies for the planet